Shirky on the semantic web


Table of Contents

There is a list of technologies that are actually political philosophy masquerading as code, a list that includes Xanadu, Freenet, and now the Semantic Web. The Semantic Web’s philosophical argument — the world should make more sense than it does — is hard to argue with. The Semantic Web, with its neat ontologies and its syllogistic logic, is a nice vision. However, like many visions that project future benefits but ignore present costs, it requires too much coordination and too much energy to effect in the real world, where deductive logic is less effective and shared worldview is harder to create than we often want to admit. [Shirky: The Semantic Web, Syllogism, and Worldview]

He does refer to a ‘Charles Dewey’, responsible for a classification scheme.


comments so far.

Sign in to comment or sign up if you are not already a member.